Category Archives: Articles

Review: BBC Archive (East Anglia Sings & Good Order)

BBC archive material: East Anglia Sings: Third Programme, Late-1947 (SFO 005) and Good Order! Ladies and Gentlemen Please – Traditional Singing and Music from The Eel’s Foot, Eastbridge, Suffolk (VT140CD) 

What we have here is a pair of releases, produced under different circumstances, which present a series of recordings made by the BBC, some in the uncertain times leading to the outbreak of what became the Second World War, and the others shortly after that momentous conflict, when perhaps the dust was still settling – a glimpse into the ordinary music making of a couple of rural East Anglian communities at time of great trauma and uncertainty around the world. The epoch itself makes the recordings of paramount historical importance, despite the fact – or perhaps because of it – that they have no relevance to or resonance with that devastating period in world history. In fact, even then folk songs were being written off with the comment that “Folksong is quaint now. Folksong is arty,” as quoted from Picture Post Magazine of 14 December 1940, on the back of the Good Order! CD. (1) The short piece does then concede that “But once this was not so” and mentions Eastbridge Eel’s Foot as a paramount example of a place “where the songs and style of the old traditional singers are still kept alive by the people themselves.” And surely this is the point and another reason for the importance of these recordings? In his Musical Traditions review of the Good Order! disc, Mike Yates made the following pertinent comment: “Many of these singers appear to have had small repertoires, each knowing only a few songs, and yet, as I said before, they continued to sing these songs over and over again…Jumbo Brightwell (and probably his father, Velvet), on the other hand, knew many songs. Luckily Jumbo, and a few of the others, were recorded on later occasions, and so we now have a much better idea of what could have once been heard sung in The Eel’s Foot. But these BBC recordings are important, because they were made at a time when the singers and listeners were all part of a living singing tradition. It was, in a real sense, community singing, where the singers, songs and audience were all part and parcel of the same thing. True, the tradition was on its last legs – which is another reason why these recordings are so important.” (2) It is fortuitous that these recordings were released, allowing us to enjoy this material, and also that one of the two recordings is, at the time of writing, still readily available. 

In 2009 Musical Traditions online magazine produced the CD of East Anglia Sings on their subsidiary Snatch’d from Oblivion label, to tie in with an article I wrote about the composer E J Moeran collecting folk songs in east Norfolk, which in itself largely comprised an article he wrote in 1936 for Norfolk Annual magazine. (3) It comprises the full 51 minute programme of the same name, broadcast on 19 November 1947, with a small section recorded in Eastbridge Eel’s Foot in Suffolk, and the majority from Sutton Windmill in Norfolk. (4) It opens with a short snatch of interview with Moeran, where he defines folk song – “that which has evolved itself in course of time, among races or communities, as opposed to that deliberately composed by individuals and written out on staves of music” – and moves to a brief introduction to The Eel’s Foot, all evocative stuff, with the received pronunciation of the presenters contrasting sharply with the song that follows, and some of which is interspersed with a Mrs Howard step dancing on a table to melodeon accompaniment. What follows are three Suffolk performances, giving between them a good indication of the sort of songs sung in the pub, and others like it. Jumbo Brightwell kicks off the proceedings in an assured, declamatory way with The False Hearted Knight, giving serious treatment to the ancient tale. He is followed – by way of great contrast – by Fred Ginger, with the humorous – or daft – The Old Sow, with its various sound effects. His light voice suits the material well. Finally from The Eel’s Foot we have Jack Clark and an assured delivery of the old warhorse The Dark-Eyed Sailor, with a determined but quite orderly chorus from the community, this in itself indicative of the familiarity they have with the material. 

The Sutton Windmill Pub c. 1950

The scene then shifts to Norfolk, with producer Martin Boddy explaining that “we drove on northwards through Yarmouth, with its river packed with the herring fleet, to the Broads country, an area which must be unmatched for its songs and singers, an area in which E J Moeran has collected songs for over twenty five years.” Moeran then adds details about the singers he has collected from in the area, including the “prince of singers, Harry Cox,” adding that “together they could sing for weeks on end. But I’m afraid tonight you can hear but a few of their lovely songs.” And that is indeed what follows. 

The singers are called upon to sing, presumably by Moeran, in what seems – by the background noise – to be a very convivial affair. Many asides and comments accompany the songs; apparently the beer flowed freely, to put the singers at their ease, and Chris Heppa, who has researched and written about the singing in the area in great length, recalls being told by the family of Jack Riseborough, a well-regarded singer but heavy drinker, of their disappointment at him not being included in the programme, the inference being that he got too drunk to give a good account of himself. (5) Be that as it may, what we do get are a song apiece from five regular singers in the pub and locality, as well as four from Harry Cox. Harry was several decades younger than his singing companions, all of whom were elderly men at this point. Their age does show to an extent, but all give very creditable performances. 

First up is John ‘Charger’ Salmons with Rigs of the Times, a common complaint about economic conditions which is fairly commonplace in the area. He has a fairly light voice and gives an assured delivery, ably helped by the chorus of the company. Charlie Chettleburgh is next: when asked to sing, he comments, “I’ll try it!” before launching into a quite fast-paced Lost Lady Found; the melodramatic story unfolds well. Harry Cox’s nut-brown voice then contributes the epic The Bonny Bunch of Roses, which Napoleonic fable seems to have caught the imagination of local rural singers (6) and then, by way of contrast, the local and more recently-composed Barton Broad Ditty – or Barton Broad Babbing Ballad (7) – which tells the gleeful tale of a farmer who got his legal comeuppance when he tried to prevent local lads from babbing for eels (8) on Barton Broad. Harry does talk a little about this at the end, once again underlying the informality of the occasion. He is followed by Walter Gales, with a high, light voice and As I Walked Out One Bright May Morning, with some joining in which becomes pretty hearty towards the end. William Miller then gives us the ubiquitous Happy and Delightful, ever-popular on pub singing occasions across East Anglia, and doubtless elsewhere, and still heard regularly today. (9) The historical The Wreck of the Ramillies is then performed by Elijah Bell, in slow, stately style which befits the sombre material, with an obviously-familiar chorus from the company. The final songs broadcast – and on the disc – are another pair from Harry Cox, the jaunty The Barley Straw, with its tale of seduction and deception of a gullible young girl by an impish – and seemingly wealthy – tinker, and then the more serious The Fowler, with its preposterous tale of a young man shooting his girlfriend whilst mistaking her for a swan (an easy mistake to make?) The singing comes to an end and we have a brief outro by a female BBC presenter, who very correctly reminds us that it was a recorded broadcast, in a very prim voice. 

In 2000 the Veteran label released a full CD of BBC recordings from Eastbridge Eel’s Foot in Suffolk – in fact, a couple of tracks are of unknown provenance, but most are from the BBC archives – recorded in 1947, as mentioned above, and also in 1938/9; as Good Order! (the longer title is given above). The booklet notes state that “The Eel’s Foot in Eastbridge, just like The Ship in Blaxhall, will go down in traditional music history as one of the great singing pubs of East Anglia. Its singers were visited over the years by many collectors, but it was the evenings recorded by the BBC in 1939, instigated by folksong scholar A L Lloyd, and in the 1947 visit arranged by the Irish composer E J Moeran, that captured the true spirit of a Saturday night’s singing in such a remote, rural pub.” What we have here are thirteen songs – one twice – and a small amount of melodeon playing, a good example of the varied programme of material performed on a Saturday night in The Eel’s Foot and other similar venues. 

The first four tracks are the same as on the East Anglia Sings disc, with the introduction to the pub and the three songs. The fifth track seems to have been recorded at the same time – 1947 – but wasn’t included in the broadcast. Velvet Brightwell gives us a slow and deliberate six minute version of The Princess Royal. The rest of the material seems to have been recorded in either 1938 or 1939. Tom Goddard contributes Poor Man’s Heaven, a light delivery. Despite his faltering at one point, and being helped out by the company, the song ends rousingly, with people joining in enthusiastically. Douglas Morling then gives us the popular The Foggy Dew, perhaps a little uncertain with the tune before it finally settles into place. He certainly gives it his all, with an effective declamatory style. Velvet Brightwell returns with another slow and deliberate performance, this time of the erotic dream of The Indian Lass. Harry ‘Crutter’ Cook contrasts this with the light and comic Duck Foot Sue, with enthusiastic participation from the company. Underneath Her Apron, a true Suffolk pub favourite, making light of a difficult situation a young girl finds herself in after carnal activity, is sung in a very assured manner by Edgar Button, with hearty chorus involvement. 

Velvet Brightwell has the most exposure on this disc, as Harry Cox did on the other one, and justifiably so, as he was a talented singer with a fairly large repertoire which he passed on to son Jumbo, equally well regarded (although not included amongst these earlier recordings). His third outing is the ubiquitous Pleasant and Delightful – an interesting comparison with William Miller’s version on East Anglia Sings. Lively and with enthusiastic chorus, it encapsulates well the type of song that remained enduringly popular. He is followed by Albert ‘Diddy’ Cook, with a rather deliberated-paced The Blackbird, which prompted the comment “Good ole Diddy!” Yes, indeed! The lighter-voiced Alec Bloomfield then contributes the stirring tale of The Farmer from Cheshire and that’s followed by Fred Ginger again, with another version of The Old Sow, with fair continuity of performance between the two recordings of about nine years apart. The final track is the playing of Jack’s the Boy on the melodeon by Jack ‘Dot’ Button, which bears only the faintest resemblance to the usual Jack’s the Lad / Sailor’s Hornpipe / College Hornpipe tune. It’s a fitting end to a programme of music making as it would have been across much of the Twentieth Century, until social changes, the fragmenting of rural communities to an extent, increased mobility and choice of amusement, and a raft of other factors precipitated the end, in most places, of such community music making, in the second half of the century. 

These are undoubtedly important recordings. They’re also very enjoyable in every respect – certainly not just musty aural documents documenting a decaying tradition. There is something very grounding in the fact that the company of singers regularly descended on their local pub, in the late 1930s, when some very dark clouds were looming, as far as European security and peace was concerned, and that they were still there when the dust was settling after the most cataclysmic conflict in human history, still singing the same songs, as their fathers and others in the community had done before them, “songs of a forgotten time – songs about highwaymen and sailing ships, about deserted soldiers and servant girls betrayed,” as the aforementioned Picture Post Magazine article of 1940 would have it. (10) There is something oddly comforting, if not darkly comic, about the thought of Fred Ginger wandering into The Eel’s Foot in 1938 or 1939, in such uncertain times, to sing The Old Sow, and then still to be doing exactly the same thing in 1947, after the devastation of the war. Truly there is something enduring here! 

The East Anglia Sings CD is sadly no longer available, since the passing of Rod Stradling and the subsequent unavailability of the releases issued by Musical Traditions. It would be well worth cajoling a copy from someone who has the disc, for want of any other option. Good Order!, which contains much information about the singers, the songs and the pub, as well as including photographs, is still available from Veteran as both CD and download veteran.co.uk. Taken together, the discs give a wonderful portrayal of the vibrant singing tradition in two local pubs (11) and are highly recommended to anyone interested in traditional singing in the region, as well as from the historical perspective. 

Chris Holderness October 2026 

Notes: 

01 Good Order! Ladies and Gentlemen Please – Traditional Singing and Music from The Eel’s Foot, Eastbridge, Suffolk Veteran VT140CD (2000) 

02 Mike Yates’ review of Good Order! in Musical Traditions (19.02.02) 

03 Chris Holderness: E J Moeran: Collecting Folk Songs in East Norfolk – In His Own Words MT219 (18.01.09) mustrad.mainlynorfolk.info 

04 East Anglia Sings: Third Programme, Late-1947 Snatch’d From Oblivion SF 005 (2009)

05 For more information about such a singing tradition see: Chris Heppa: Harry Cox and his Friends: Song Transmission in an East Norfolk Singing Community c1896-1960 EFDSS Journal (10/01) 

06 See, for example, Sam Larner: A Garland for Sam Topic 12T244 (1974) and Cruising Round Yarmouth Musical Traditions MTCD369-0 (2014) 

07 See the Alan Lomax recordings: What Will Become of England? Rounder 11661-1839-2 (2000) 

08 ‘Babbing’ is catching eels without using a hook, by threading a bundle of worms onto string or yarn 

09 See, for example, Bob Scarce’s version on the previously-reviewed The Larks They Sang Melodious XTRA 1141 (1974) 

10 Given on the back of the CD inlay – VT140CD, as 01 above 

11 Sutton Windmill closed in October 1970, but Eastbridge Eel’s Foot still thrives as a pub.

Share:

Review: Billy Bennington ‘The Barford Angel

Veteran VT152CD 

In 1973, Topic Records put out an LP of instrumental music from this region – English Country Music from East Anglia (1) – which proved to be highly influential for the burgeoning scene of musicians and enthusiasts dedicated to promoting the idea that England had a vibrant tradition of music-making, which could be celebrated in just the same way as it was in Scotland and Ireland. The LP comprised music from four performers, one of whom was Billy Bennington, dulcimer player from Barford. I have reviewed this album previously (2) and don’t propose to revisit that ground here. Suffice to say that the LP certainly showed that East Anglia was a place where, in the 1970s, a few traditional performers could still be found. In 1987, a full LP of Billy Bennington’s music – The Barford Angel – was released on the tiny East Anglian Life label (3), further demonstrating Billy’s virtuosity on the instrument. In 2005 Veteran reissued the LP on compact disc, adding the tracks from the Topic LP too, to create a vibrant musical portrait of this dulcimer virtuoso. 

Billy Bennington was born in Barford in 1900, an area of several ‘dulcimore’ players, a tradition which seems to have emanated out of Norwich, which was also noteworthy for makers of the instrument. He took lessons from local musician and band leader Billy Cooper after 1912 – whose son, also Billy Cooper, was also a prominent player, (4) and in the years after the First World War Billy teamed up with Billy Cooper junior and fiddler Walter Baldwin (5) to play in pubs all over Norfolk. From then on Billy fulfilled the role of local musician, whilst working as a gardener, developing an ornate but precise style of playing. These recordings were made towards the end of his life – he died in October 1986, a year after the bulk of the recordings were made – but his talents seem to have been in no way diminished by his age. 

What we have here is over an hour of Billy’s repertoire: the social dances – hornpipes, polkas, schottisches and waltzes – marches and a couple of popular song tunes from his younger years. Hornpipes are well represented: a slightly unusual, rolling version of the ubiquitous Flowers of Edinburgh, (mistitled Yarmouth Hornpipe on the Topic LP), a sprightly medley of the local perennial favourites Yarmouth Hornpipe and Sheringham Breakdown, as well as the equally well-known Sailor’s Hornpipe (containing a snippet of Flowers of Edinburgh along the way), all at a moderate, assured pace. Schottisches are also well represented, illustrating how commonplace this couple dance was in these rural communities: Herbert Sadd’s Schottische, a rather florid and complex version of the tune more commonly known as Mountain Belle Schottische, and which came from the highly-regarded local player of that name, followed by an untitled Schottische and yet another unnamed, which track then nicely changes tempo into a Step Dance. 

Polkas are equally well represented, with the wonderful Gay Ladies Polka and also two others which have been taken up by musicians locally, and played as a set – Pony Trot Polka and On the Green, the latter with its improvised section. Here are the originals in all their glory. Likewise a slow and stately version of the somewhat hackneyed Redwing, starting on the second strain of the tune, and none the worse for that. Also the song Going to the Derby, making an effective polka, and which Katie’s Quartet reworked as ‘BB’s’ (6) It’s easy to see the extent to which Billy Bennington was such an influence on younger performers, and the worth of these recordings in that respect. 

The solitary jig, Rose Cottage, was named by Billy for his cottage and he comments that it was used for the Norfolk Long Dance (one of many, often untitled, tunes that local musicians had for the purpose). Billy once again gives an unhurried, assured performance. Waltzes are evident in the form of two distinct tunes called Dulcie Bell. The first is the ‘usual’ tune of this name, also played by Billy Cooper (junior) and probably written by his father, ‘Old Cooper’. (7) It certainly lives up to its name, with its Edwardian elegance and charm. Much the same could be said of the other, Dulcie Bell 2, which appeared on the Topic LP as ‘Dulcie Belle’ and for which Billy didn’t have a name. There are also two marches – a favourite type of tune – the Sousa-composed On Parade and The Gunner’s March, used, as Billy describes, for the Military Two-Step. 

An unusual item is the tour de force performance of the American string band favourite The Chicken Reel. Where Billy got it from is unknown, but here is proof that the cross-Atlantic exchange of tunes was not a one-way flow in the early Twentieth Century (as exemplified also by the popularity of such tunes as Redwing and Whistling Rufus). There is also the dulcimer party-piece The Bells of St Mary’s, and the rest of the running time comprises popular songs of the earlier Twentieth Century, When Johnny Comes to Town, Lovely Lucerne, Obidiah, I Like to Say Good Morning and the sublime My Beloved Cornelia, with its effective mandolin mimicry. 

In all, here we have a wonderful musical portrait of an extraordinary rural musician, a man who operated within the loose borders of tradition, but whose virtuosity took this music to a high level indeed. The CD is subtitled ‘Norfolk dulcimer and dialect’, and what we also get are several spoken passages as introductions to tunes, with wonderful – and sometimes hilarious – anecdotes about Billy’s life and experiences as a musician, all adding to the richness of the listening experience. This is, possibly unsurprisingly, the only full album dedicated to an East Anglian dulcimer player. (8) For that reason alone it is essential for anyone’s music collection, but it is much more than just a historical document: it is a vibrant aural portrait of a wonderful musician. 

The sound quality is excellent and the CD booklet contains much information and several photographs, as is usual with Veteran releases. There really isn’t anything lacking; it’s a highly recommended album, available at the time of writing as both CD and download from Veteran. 

Chris Holderness May 2026

Notes: 

1. English Country Music from East Anglia Topic 12TS229, 1973 

2. Reviewed in the January 2026 newsletter 

3. Billy Bennington The Barford Angel East Anglian Life EAL-1, 1987 

4. Billy Cooper (junior) can be heard on English Country Music Topic TSCD607, 2000, Heel and Toe: Veteran VT150CD, 2005, and ‘I Thought I Was the Only One!’ Dulcimer Playing in East Anglia Veteran VTDC12CD, 2015. The LP version of the first was reviewed in the newsletter for December 2025, the second was reviewed recently in another newsletter; a review from 2015 of the latter can be found at mustrad.mainlynorfolk.info 

5. Not to be confused with Shipdham fiddler Walter Bulwer, as sometimes happens due to the similarity of the name. Walter Baldwin was a blacksmith in Hingham who was regarded as a fine fiddler. He was never recorded. His image can be seen in the photo of the ‘Hingham Minstrels’: see Chris Holderness: The Devil’s Box in the East: Traditional Fiddle Playing in Norfolk and Suffolk, 2024, at eatmt.org.uk 

6. Recorded on Katie’s Quartet Old Hat Music OH3CD, 1996 

7. Billy Cooper’s version of Dulcie Bell can be heard on TSCD607 and VT150CD, as above 8. More players, and more material by Billy Bennington, can be heard on VTDC12CD, as above.

Share:

Tune of the month – Walter Bulwer’s “Number 5”

Walter Bulwer was a fiddle player, born in Shipdham (Norfolk) in 1888; where he lived all his life. You can read Reg Hall’s profile of Walter and Daisy Bulwer on the EATMT website here.

There is more information on the Bulwers in Chris Holderness’ article here. Something to be aware of if you are relying on old website bookmarks is that the Mustrad website no longer exists. Its content is now available on the Mainly Norfolk website.

Probably the two most popular of Walter’s tunes today are simply know as “Walter Bulwer’s Polka No 2” and “Walter Bulwer’s Polka No 1” – but there are at least four other polka tunes we have from Walter which don’t have names, to say nothing of tunes for other dances. 

Walter was adept at picking up tunes by ear and adapting then as he played – but also owned a good collection of sheet music; sadly now lost. It is very plausible that these un-named polka tunes have origins in that collection of sheet music. Following a conversation between Adrian and Sue Carlton and Geoff Crabb the concertina maker, we are now able to put a name to the tune previously known as “Walter Bulwer’s Polka #5” – “The Cromartie Polka March”.

You can hear Walter, along with Daisy, dulcimer player Billy Cooper and banjo player Edna Wortley playing the tune in around 1960 as track 18 on the CD “Heel and Toe” – published by Veteran ( it’s VT150CD – which is available to buy through Veteran’s bandcamp page ).

EATMT’s “brown book” Before the night was out – by Katie Howson has a transcription of the 1960 recording.

The full score for the Cromartie Polka March composed by “R. Heath” can be found in “Turner’s March Album of Solos for the Banjo #1” – but in case you don’t have a copy of that to hand, then here’s the basic form of the melody – an interesting exercise to compare it with the 1960 recording and it’s transcription. Same tune do you think? I wonder how many of Walter’s other un-named tunes have an origin in a long forgotten piece of sheet music.

Andrew Collins, May 2026

Share:

Cohen Braithwaite-Kilcoyne on the evolution of traditional music

With the summer now truly acumin in, our thoughts are turning to our Summer Sessions event at Stowmarket’s John Peel Centre on June 5th. Headlining this year is Cohen Braithwaite-Kilcoyne, whose mastery of the Anglo concertina and melodeon – not to mention his commanding voice – put him at the forefront of the next generation keeping the traditional music of England very much alive. We managed to find time in his touring schedule for a quick virtual coffee to find out a little more about how and why his love of traditional music began…

Let’s start at the beginning, Cohen. What’s your first memory or experience of traditional music?

That’s a really good question. Probably the first encounter I remember was when I was about six at primary school, and a pair of musicians – a fiddle player and a guitarist – came in to play some folk tunes. I’d never heard folk tunes before. I didn’t really know what they were but I do remember them talking about their music and their instruments.

Do you remember any of the music?

Well, I don’t remember who the musicians were, which is of course a shame because I’d love to write them a note and say thank you so much. But the one song I remember them definitely singing was Cockles and Mussels – and I remember that because that’s got a ghost verse at the end. And that really captured me, because it’s a bit scary and I was really into Scooby Doo at the time…

Actually, a couple of weeks ago I was invited to a primary school – not my own, unfortunately! – to share my folk tunes and my instruments and tell them a bit about what I do. That was a nice full circle moment.

What do you think made folk music stick for you? 

Yeah, I mean, I didn’t go from that first exposure to folk music at six straight to folk clubs – there were lots of chance encounters along the way, all of which started getting me interested in folk music.

Take Brian Peters, for example. So in addition to being a great squeeze box player, one of his other claims to fame is that he’s done quite a bit of music library work – and some of his soundtrack library recordings had got picked up on various TV shows, including SpongeBob SquarePants, which was another thing I was obsessed with when I was about seven. And, as strange as that might sound, hearing those little folk tunes crop up in the background of shows like that helped introduce the melodies to the ear without me even making the immediate connection that I was hearing a folk tune, or a jig, or a hornpipe. Likewise, John Kirkpatrick played the concertina on a Phone4U advert so when I did become more into traditional music, I was already familiar with the sounds of these instruments and some of these tunes – as I suppose we all are, really.

How would you define traditional music? Or, to put another way: what is it – and why does it matter?

I think the definition that I like the best is the one Steve Roud offers in Folk Song in England. He says a folk song is a song that is sung by a folk singer, and a folk singer is someone that sings folk songs. And I just think that’s so beautifully put. It’s the fact that the song or the tune or whatever it is, has been absorbed by a community and has lost its sense of ownership and its sense of origin, and in doing so the community has shaped it and evolved it and changed it and filtered it. It might have originally been a composed piece. It might have had a known composer, but that origin becomes less relevant. It’s all about that journey. 

Are there any particular songs where you find this to be particularly true?

One example that maybe springs to mind is on my first solo album [Outway Songster]. There’s a song on there called the Country Carrier, which has a known writer. It was written by a man called Harry Clifton, who was a really, really prolific songwriter of the 19th century. What’s interesting is that although it was hugely popular with folk singers of the 19th and 20th centuries, they would all probably have been unconscious of the fact that they were singing a Music Hall song. The ways in which it was performed – particularly into the 20th century – were quite divorced from how it must have started off its life. Melodically of course, you can still see a thread that links it back to Harry Clifton’s original tune, but it’s quite distinct – and some of the verses have changed as well. There’s a nice natural track of evolution.

So the musical evolution is one thing – how about the influence of place? Does this change the song or tradition in any way?

Sure. I mean, that can be one of the really exciting things about working with traditional repertories: exploring repertoires that have a local connection. 

When I started getting interested in folk music, that was one of the things that really drew me in: on the one hand you had all the music being produced in America, singing about places that I’d never heard of – and then with folk music you had tunes that were named after places in Birmingham that I’d been to, roads I’d walked down, areas that I knew. 

And there was that real sense of immediacy and familiarity – and that was one of the things that really hooked me when I started really getting into traditional song was that sense of place and that sense of regionality. 

That’s a very special thing – and being a region where such a huge amount of material was collected, we see this too…

Absolutely. One of the things that I found interesting about the East Anglian repertoire is that – and this might be slightly romanticised – when Vaughan Williams was doing his collecting in East Anglia, he had this theory that, because it’s closer to the Eastern Sea and to Scandinavia, that there’s a link between the Nordic repertoire and some of the melodies that he was finding in the East, particularly around King’s Lynn. He reckoned that there was this sort of Scandinavian quality to a lot of the melodies that they were singing there – The Captain’s Apprentice is one example that he particularly drew out. That tune has such an incredible, otherworldly melody, which he likened to Scandinavian folk tunes. 

Final question Cohen: as we’re speaking close to May Day I wondered if you could share a seasonal song that you like?

One of my favourite May song recordings is one that the band Magpie Lane did on their first album, which was called the Oxford Ramble. Their last track is just called May Day Carol, and it’s got the most charming tune to it. Of course there are so many May tunes out there, but that’s probably my favourite.

Cohen will be headlining our Summer Sessions concert at the John Peel Centre, Stowmarket on Friday 5 June and tickets are available now. For more information about Cohen’s music and other upcoming concerts and tours, visit his website.

Share:

Review: Harry Cox: English Folk Singer and Sings English Love Songs

Harry Cox: English Folk Singer and Sings English Love Songs
(EFDSS LP1004 and DTS LFX 4)


Two for the price of one this month, as up for scrutiny are a brace of Harry Cox albums, both released in 1965, and which cemented his reputation as one of England’s finest traditional singers. A great deal has been written about him and his singing community and I don’t propose to duplicate that here. The reader is referred to the booklet notes of the Topic Records double CD The Bonny Labouring Boy (1), Chris Heppa’s published research (2) and several articles produced for the East Anglian Traditional Music Trust (3) as a starting point. Rather, I’d like to put into the spotlight a pair of records which were released – in Britain – within a few months of each other and which gave a fair aural portrait of Harry’s repertoire, and something of the context, at a time when there were precious few LPs available of traditional English singers.


Prior to these releases there was little indeed. The first LP of a traditional English singer seems to be the American release of Sam Larner: Now is the Time for Fishing on the Folkways label (1961) (4). In Britain, Topic dipped their toe in the water with The Willett Family: The Roving Journeyman in 1962 (5) and the English Folk Dance and Song Society followed with Bob and Ron Copper: Traditional Songs from Rottingdean in 1964. (6) Harry’s singing had been heard across several volumes of the Caedmon series The Folk Songs of Britain (1961) (7) and on one track of an EP: The Barley Mow in 1960. (8) Then followed the two discs in question – quite an exposure for one singer, given the general paucity of such material at the time.

Peter Kennedy recorded Harry extensively for the BBC between 1953 and 1965. It is a selection of that material which appears on these LPs. Harry Cox: English Folk Singer was first released by EFDSS, to members only, in 1965, “as a tribute to a great English folk-singer in the year of his 80th birthday” (9) and was later released more generally as part of their “Folk Classics” series. (10) The first side kicks off with the local tale, the Barton Broad Ballad, in which local lads fell foul of a farmer whilst babbing (11) for eels, only to have the farmer get his comeuppance in court. What follows is a well-chosen programme: the murderous tale of The ‘Prentice Boy, with its wonderful irregular rhythm, the nautical old chestnut Windy Old Weather, a perennial favourite in East Anglia, the tale of highway robbery and a sticky end in Newlyn Town and the epic Napoleonic The Bonny Bunch of Roses. These last two in particular demonstrate well Harry’s consummate dispassionate delivery, allowing the story to take its course. A short hard-luck tale, Adieu to Old England and the story of thwarted lust and a supposedly happy ending, Blackberry Fold, end the side – a wonderful
collection of characters woven through these tales, with Harry’s delivery allowing it all to unfold each time.

Peter Kennedy evidently found it necessary to explain Harry’s style and delivery, to fellow EFDSS members, in the sleeve notes: “At first hearing of Harry Cox you may remark on the ‘dry’ impersonality and monotony of his style; for many of us in the Society it has taken five, ten or even twenty years to appreciate the subtleties of his performances. How impressed you may be, at first, with the tricks and dramatic effects of a concert singer of folk songs, but how soon tire of repeat performances! With a traditional singer of Harry Cox’s calibre the process is reversed. Each time you hear him the songs grow on you, for he presents them with complete selflessness and sincerity. To watch him, with his eyes closed or looking
into the distance beyond the company, you realise that he is living the story of each song. Contrary to what so many have said of traditional singers he is, in fact, giving an artistic performance into which he pours as much, if not more nervous energy than the best stage singers. Each song is imbued, however, with the same dry cynicism as when he tells a story or speaks about his family background and hard-working country life…” Well said! It is indeed the case and makes for rewarding repeated listening.

Which brings us to the second side. This is more varied. Rather in the style of the aforementioned ground-breaking LP Sam Larner: Now is the Time For Fishing, with its lengthy sections of talk, here we have songs mixed with Harry talking about himself, his father and also about singing and playing. There are also examples of his fiddle and melodeon playing, giving a rounded picture of the consummate rural entertainer. First there is the comic and cumulative Widdlecombe Fair, followed straight away by Harry playing the tune of The Ploughboy on the fiddle (a fairly rare example of an East Anglian musician playing an air on the fiddle, or any other instrument for that matter). The complaint of What Will Become of England? follows some talk, and then further talk is interspersed with instrumental tracks: a waltz on the melodeon, and then Yarmouth Hornpipe and Woodland
Flowers
, also on that instrument, the latter of which Harry described as being for a schottische. Later we have two hornpipes on the fiddle: Yarmouth Hornpipe again (and interesting to note how different it is from the version on the melodeon) and Meg Merrilees – a rarity in East Anglia. (12) The snippets of Harry’s speech give a fascinating evocation of his life and family, and also just how much music he got from his father Bob, a man with a great local reputation as both singer and fiddler. The last three tracks are back to Harry’s songs, all with a theme of love or lust: The Foggy Dew, Nancy and Johnny and Firelock Stile, the last with its warning of the possible medical consequences of such carnal behaviour.

Harry Cox Sings English Love Songs, also released in 1965, on DTS Records, (13) presents another selection of Peter Kennedy recordings. The album was also released in the United States – before Britain, in 1964, if discographical information is to be believed – on the Folk-Legacy label. (14) Here we have purely songs, fourteen of them, with the loose theme of love – although lust, infidelity and comeuppance would be better descriptors for several of them. All good, wholesome stuff, of course, being folk songs. Harry works his way through the breezy Seventeen Come Sunday, the bucolic love story of The Spotted Cow and on to Next Monday Morning, with a young girl’s longing for matrimony. Things move into the more comic with the bawdy tale of The Greasy Cook, often titled Butter and Cheese and All. (15) Then the mutual love of Colin and Phoebe, even if she mistrusts his intentions at first, followed by the tale of a cuckolded sailor taking it out violently on his unfaithful wife in The Birmingham Man. The side ends with the classic theme of forbidden love across the class divide, this time with tragic consequences, with Betsy the Serving Maid.

The second side continues this theme: Bonny Labouring Boy considers the impossibility of such attraction, when social status was so rigid. A feisty young female disguises herself as a man and runs off to join the army in The Female Drummer, seemingly with no motive other than serving her country, in this version, only to be ‘discovered’ at the end of the song. And so the theme of the tribulations of love continues with The Squire and the Gypsy, of which the title says it all, and the popular comic old tale of Marrowbones, where a man gets his own back on his unfaithful wife. Next up is The Groggy Old Tailor, who gets his comeuppance rather violently at the hands of the “bold drover”, who wasn’t happy about what he was up to with his wife. We then conclude with the bawdy Up to the Rigs of London Town, in which a countryman gets the better of a prostitute, and finally the sustained double entendre of The German Musicianer, to end the LP on an appropriately light-hearted note. Quite a romp through a series of larger-than-life characters and situations, and yet somehow completely ordinary and earthy. It is very easy to sit back and get lost in their tales, which is precisely as it should be, of course.

Norwich singer Peter Coleman, who knew Harry Cox well, described him as a ‘colossus’, standing head and shoulders over all others. This may be a fair assessment but it should not be forgotten that Harry was the product of his community, one which happened to be very rich in traditional singers, as Chris Heppa’s research (16) has pointed out. Also, just as there is far more to country blues than just Charlie Patton and Robert Johnson, there were a great many significant tradition-bearers of English folk song. None were recorded as extensively as Harry though, and judging by this pair of LPs, it is not difficult to see why. His command of the material, obvious relish in the tales and awareness of the importance of what he was custodian of, make him a supremely important figure in English folk song. When these two LPs hit the shelves in 1965 they must have been a revelation. It is easy to see why they served as such an inspiration for so many others for such a long time.

It ought to be a reviewer’s job to point out faults and failings as well as the positives, but in this instance I have to admit to being at a loss. What is tragic is that these two LPs have been so unavailable for so long. Peter Kennedy did reissue both, in expanded forms, as cassettes and then CDs, on his Folktrax label, but these have not been in print for quite some time.
(17) The American, Folk-Legacy, version of Sings English Love Songs is now available as a CD from Smithsonian Folkways (18) but the EFDSS LP remains long out of print. With the current rebranding of that institution’s commercial face as Folk England, nothing could be more fitting from its back catalogue to illustrate exactly what such a new name should represent than this collection from Harry Cox.

Chris Holderness April 2026


Notes:

  1. Harry Cox: The Bonny Labouring Boy Topic TSCD512D. Easily available and highly recommended as an extensive collection of Harry’s music.
  2. Particularly: Chris Heppa: Harry Cox and His Friends: Song Transmission in an East Norfolk Singing Community, c1896-1960 A Life in Song: EFDSS Journal, Oct. 2001
  3. Shirley Collins and Chris Heppa: Harry Cox in the ‘Portraits’ series; Chris Holderness: The Broads Brothers: Harry and Fred 2021
  4. Sam Larner: Now is the Time For Fishing Folkways FG 3507 1961
  5. The Willett Family: The Roving Journeyman Topic 12T84 1962
  6. Bob and Ron Copper: Traditional Songs From Rottingdean EFDSS LP1002 1964
  7. See the discography published on the EATMT site: Chris Holderness: When I Sing a Song, My Mind is On It: a Discography of Recordings of Harry Cox – Produced 50 Years After his Death. In retrospect, this could have given fuller details about the LPs in question, but
    otherwise is comprehensive
  8. The Barley Mow (Songs From the Village Inn) His Master’s Voice 7EG 8288 1960
  9. Harry Cox: English Folk Singer EFDSS LP1004 1965. The original release had a black and white photograph of Harry on the sleeve
  10. I haven’t been able to find out a date of reissue. The catalogue number remained the same but the original sleeve was replaced with a painting by John Crane
  11. The practice of fishing for eels without hooks – using a bundle of worms threaded on wool, attached to a line and pole.
  12. For a discussion of Harry’s fiddle playing, see: Phil HeathColeman: Harry Cox: Norfolk Fiddler Extraordinaire Musical Traditions MT284 2013. This can be found at mustrad.mainlynorfolk.info Since Rod Stradling’s passing, the site was unavailable. It is now temporarily so as above, although searc facilities don’t lead to it. The site should be found a more permanent home before long. Also relevant is: Chris Holderness: The Devil’s Box in the East: Traditional Fiddle Playing in Norfolk and Suffolk – published on the EATMT site in Oct. 2024
  13. DTS Records was an output of Davies Transcription Services, operated by recording engineer Sean Davies. He seems to have had connections with EFDSS and several recordings of folk music were issued on this small label
  14. Harry Cox Sings English Love Songs Folk-Legacy FSE20 / FSB20
  15. This has a different sleeve to the British release
  16. See Sam Larner’s version on Folkways FG 3507, as (4) above
  17. As (2) above
  18. Details in the discography, as (7) above
  19. It can be obtained from folkways.si.edu Incidentally, the service is impressive – upon ordering from them, the merchandise will be with you in about two working days, via FedEx, all the way from Washington DC!
Share: