A short history of the rural concert party in East Anglia
As I have recently described the “Norfolk Tune-Up” events as a cross between a concert party and a ‘led session’, it is perhaps time to investigate the history of concert parties in the region, and to see how it fits in with what’s happening today.
The idea of a ‘concert party’ in rural England seems to have evolved from localised music gatherings in the eighteenth century, with various organising bodies presiding over them. Originally they were probably heavily dependent on the patronage, and possible involvement, of the local gentry – such as music clubs run by the more well-heeled members of the community – but there also seem to have been a plethora of more informal gatherings, utilising local working people, with the fiddle to the fore. These probably existed at the same time as travelling troupes brought music and theatre to remote areas, and performances seem to have blended traditional material with social, cultural or political expression, as was deemed necessary or noteworthy at the time. As well as what went on in villages, towns acted as social and musical hubs, with frequent music and dance assemblies, although presumably largely intended for those a little way up the social scale. There is much evidence of varied types of music making and other entertainment, put together in programmes, as “concert parties”, very often tied to calendar festivals and to raise money for local institutions. Unsurprisingly, central to these occasions were the contributions of those who sang in the pubs and played music for the local dancing.
An example of this is Charlie Stringer, of Wickham Skeith, Suffolk, whose singing appears on the Who Owns the Game? album (1). The LP notes comment that “Apart from pub singing, he also used to sing in a concert party, and has a photograph of himself and a friend wearing dresses and singing Two Little Girls in Blue!” Many concert parties seem to have been purely village affairs, although some did travel to neighbouring places to put on shows. The emphasis was on variety of material – music, song and dance, coupled with humour, monologues and presumably whatever local people had to offer. In the early twentieth century there was quite a craze for “Pierrot shows”. These took their inspiration from the Italian Commedia dell’arte, which flourished across Europe between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries. The emphasis here was on sentimental or melancholic songs about love, or lighthearted skits of comic song or dance, the performers having whitened faces and distinctive, oversized clothes, often as a ‘pierrot’ costume. There is a wonderful photograph of musicians Walter and Daisy Bulwer of Shipdham in Norfolk wearing such costumes, sometime in the 1930s. (2)
Norfolk musician and horseman Ray Hubbard, who lived for much of his life in Dickleburgh, organised concert parties with his wife Pamela, in the late 1950s onwards, which seem to have been very successful – as mentioned in the notes to his Norfolk Bred CD: “Ray and Pamela started the Concert Party that was known as “Norfolk Bred”…Ray came up with the idea of a concert party (to raise money for bell renovation in the church), with choir members performing. The news of the concert party spread and soon they were being asked to perform in other villages, sometimes going out two or three times a week. The Concert Party was a variety show with a changing cast, depending on where they were travelling to, but regulars included Ray Leader on accordion and Revis Leader on drums. There would be anything from a skiffle group to a lady who did monologues. Ray wrote sketches and performed in a number of roles, including ventriloquist, one-man band and soloist on the musical saw – not forgetting his accordeon playing, which often knitted the proceedings together.” (3)
More recently, and of more direct relevance to present happenings, is the fact that John and Katie Howson put together the “Old Hat Concert Party” in Suffolk in the early 1980s. This brought together older generation, traditional performers for a varied evening’s entertainment in various venues in the county and further afield. They have given information about the Concert Party’s activities in one of the Portraits series of articles, on the EATMT website (4), and I don’t propose to reproduce that here. However, Barry Callaghan, reviewing the CD reissue of the Old Hat Concert Party recording, for Musical Traditions magazine, summarised the outfit and its activities very well. Writing of 1986, when the album was originally released on cassette, he comments: “The Concert Party had coalesced into a recognisable entity and was travelling widely, bringing the flavour of old-time East Anglian rural social music to wider audiences.” He adds that there was “a wide network of musicians and step-dancers spreading their congenial brand of music, singing and backchat round the pubs of central Suffolk” and that the CD, and Concert Party nights in general, comprised “ensemble instrumental pieces – with varying combinations of participants – framing a selection of songs, stories and step-dances to solo instrumentals.” (5) A wonderful opportunity to entertain, whilst giving great exposure to these older performers and their music.
The Old Hat Concert Party continued into the 1990s, until there was a hiatus towards the end of the decade, after several key performers had passed away. It was then revitalised for a few more years by “the addition of Reg’s (Reader) grandson Tom Knights, David Chilvers and his granddaughters Jessica and Amy, Steven Matthews, Ray Hubbard and steppers Lenny Whiting and Percy and Doreen West.” (6)
In Norfolk, and about the same time as the revitalised Concert Party above, various of us in the band “Rig-Jig-Jig” – formed to promote and play the traditional music of the county – put in place similar events, in the same kind of way, and featuring largely the same traditional performers, as well as regular contributions from former Cromer lifeboat coxswain – and step dancer and singer Richard Davies and his daughter Fiona. For the best part of a decade we had a great many wonderful afternoons and evenings in a wide variety of locations across the county, and occasionally further afield. The venture yielded two CDs of live performances, All at Sea and All Ashore, both recorded in Wells-next-the-Sea, the former on the Albatros ship and the latter in the Granary Theatre – hence the names of the discs. (7)
So, the idea of a “concert party” in this traditional, rural context is a forum by which tradition bearers can perform, in a varied evening, held together by a band playing tunes with a local provenance. It has proven to be very successful and enjoyable in equal measure. Even though most of the older generation traditional performers have now passed away, it is hoped that the “concert party” aspect of the “Norfolk Tune-Up” events will continue in this vein, offering people the chance to perform as part of a vibrant event, which also showcases the region’s rich musical tradition for the wider public. Another aspect of the “Tune-Up” shows is to give people the opportunity to play along with the tunes, as played by the band, to enable those to have wider currency too. In all, the emphasis is on the entertainment value of this music, and hopefully this is fully in keeping with the former Old Hat Concert Party events in Suffolk and the Rig-a-Jig-Jig shows in Norfolk, as well as retaining the spirit of rural concert parties and similar events in years gone by.
Chris Holderness February 2026
Notes:
Who Owns the Game? Traditional Songs and Melodeon Tunes from Central Suffolk Home-Made Music HMM LP302. Reissued as Veteran VT130CD. Reviewed in the last newsletter.
Given in the sleeve notes to the Topic reissue of English Country Music. 12T296. Reviewed in December’s newsletter.
Ray Hubbard Norfolk Bred Veteran VT155CD. Reviewed in an earlier newsletter. The quote at the top of this article is the title of one of his comic monologues, a regular feature of his repertoire, and included on the album. With reference to the two different spellings of ‘accordion’: the older performers rarely used the term ‘melodeon’; ‘accordion’ refers to a piano accordion and ‘accordeon’ to a melodeon.
A colourful and joyous occasion, as it’s always been whenever I’ve attended, either as a participant or as a spectator.
I had the pleasure of dancing Cotswold Morris with Mark Jones when I first started with Golden Star in Norwich around about the year 2000, which coincidentally was the first year Ouse Washes hosted a day of dance focussed on the East Anglian tradition of Molly dancing. Mark also danced with Ouse Washes over in West Norfolk, and tragically died in a road accident on the way home from a practice session in 2005. Mark was a great character, never had a bad word for anyone, he absolutely loved dancing, and it’s fitting that Ouse Washes chose to dedicate their own Molly day to Mark’s memory.
Although the day no longer includes coach tours taking the dancers and musicians to Little Downham and other nearby villages, Ely has several good dances spots in the city centre and alongside the river, the day starting and ending at The Cutter Inn.
Molly dancing was “revived”, I think I am right in saying in the 1970s, firstly by Cambridge Morris Men at a local level, and then taken up by the newly formed Seven Champions group based in Kent, who soon became popular with audiences at folk festivals and dance events around the country. Numerous Molly dance groups subsequently sprang up across East Anglia, some taking their influence from the Seven Champions and others developing their own dance styles and distinctive costumes. These range from the bright colours and flamboyant dance style of Gog Magog through to the corduroys, tweed jackets and smudged faces of the steadier Mepal Molly Men.
Elaine Bradtke’s * book “Truculent Rustics – Molly Dancing in East Anglia before 1940“ contains extensive historic references, mainly but not exclusively taken from Cambridgeshire, often linking the dancing and other activities with Plough Monday. As happened then and still happens today, men often dance in women’s attire. Ribbons and tall hats were features in some villages, as were brooms and collecting boxes. Funnily enough these also still feature today, with many variations and alternatives. *(The Folklore Society, 1999 reprinted 2000, ISBN 0 903515 18 0)
There are possibly more people dancing Molly now than ever before, and not just in East Anglia. This year’s event saw groups from The Vale of Evesham (Asum Gras), Bristol (Molly No Mates), Kent (Seven Champions and Madder Mill) and Leicestershire (Black Annis) alongside groups based in Norfolk, Essex and of course Cambridgeshire. The furthest travelled were, however, Green River Tap and Dye from Massachusetts, USA, appearing for a second year in succession. Quite a journey!
The day began with each group dancing once in turn, followed by all dancing together in a massed dance to “Rolling Home”, a song Mark particularly enjoyed.
The day’s dancing ended with a broom dance competition. Broom dancing seems to be on an upward trend ! This year, and not for the first time, the trophy was won by Nancy the dancing dog and her handler, representing Black Annis. Hopefully they’ll be back to defend the trophy next year.
Here are a few of my photos. For some better photos and for some video clips I suggest the Facebook pages of Ouse Washes Molly Dancers, Belchamp Morris, Gog Magog Molly and Sas Astro. I am sure there are many more too. Ten out of Ten to Ouse Washes for their hosting of the event.
A Good Ole Norfolk “Tune-Up” at The Reindeer, Norwich Sunday 25th January 2026
On a rather dank and chilly winter afternoon a fair throng decided to get in out of the weather and found themselves in The Reindeer for the first of the “Norfolk Tune-Up” events. As to the name, when the old boys got together for an occasion of music making, it was never a ‘session’, even less a ‘concert’ of any kind; most likely it was getting together for a ‘tune-up’’, as they would have it, and so we have decided to use the phrase, as singularly appropriate. By the start time of 4.00, the pub was gratifyingly full and others added to the company as the afternoon wore on.
What followed was the best part of three hours of music, song and step dance, just about all with a Norfolk provenance in one way or another. It kicked off with a couple of sets of tunes, the music being led by the fairly recently-formed Unthank Irregulars band, but with many people playing along, ranged around the stage area. More sets of tunes – hornpipes, polkas, jigs, schottisches and waltzes, the usual fare – followed at intervals, being interspersed with songs from several different performers, as well as a step dance, as fancy took. Of particular note was the couple dancing of Barry Mobbs and Monica Rackham, adding grace and a visual spectacle to the proceedings, with impressive frequency. In addition, both Richard Blake and Tom Knights gave us several dulcimer solo pieces. Too many people contributed to be noted individually, but special mention should perhaps be made of Sheila Park, who gave us several songs, some of which she learned in person from Harry Cox.
A wonderful atmosphere pervaded the proceedings and it was gratifying to see people of all ages enjoying the event. By the time things were drawing to a close, the pub had apparently run out of cask ale and everyone seemed contented that it was a great success.
Future events
The plan is to continue with these “Tune-Up” events monthly, in different places around the county. The stand-alone events are on Sundays, at different times, depending upon what suits the venue. In addition, there will be a “Tune-Up” aspect to other, larger events – dates below. In many ways a cross between a ‘led session’ and a concert party, the emphasis is on varied entertainment, but also on participation. Many of the tunes have been posted online on the website and more will follow. In addition, there are plans to add recordings, all to help people to learn the tunes. Do come along to join in the tunes, sing a song or do a turn, or just soak up the atmosphere of this vibrant local musical heritage.
Dates
“Tune-Up” dates – all Sundays:
26 April: Briston Three Horseshoes 1-4pm
17 May: Erpingham Spread Eagle 4.30-7.30pm
14 June: Shotesham Globe 4-7pm
30 August: North Lopham King’s Head 4-7pm
18 October: Dereham Cock Inn 3-6pm
In addition, there’ll be a “Tune-Up” element to the following:
Saturday 28 March: Briston Copeman Centre 12.00 – 4.00: A Celebration of Norfolk Music, Song and Dance
Saturday 11 and Sunday 12 July: Strumpshaw Tree Fair – details to follow
Sunday 19 July: Warham Three Horseshoes – Stepdance Day – details to follow.
Saturday 8 August – Thorpe Abbot Folk Day – details to follow
Saturday 5 or Sunday 6 September – Bungay Folk Festival – details to follow
Saturday 19 September: Stowmarket Traditional Music Day – details to follow
Review Who Owns the Game? Traditional Songs and Melodeon Tunes from Central Suffolk (Home-Made Music HMM LP 302; reissued: Veteran VT130CD)
This LP seems to have come about as a joint venture between Mike Yates and John Howson, and was first issued on the former’s short-lived Home-Made Music label, before being reissued by Veteran, first as a cassette and later as CD VT130CD. (1) I have to admit that it was one of the very first recordings of local traditional music that really captivated me, and inspired me to seek out more. It features three singers and three melodeon players, all seasoned pub performers from central Suffolk, with a programme of a selection of the sort of stuff that would have been heard in traditional music gatherings in the pubs of the area. Having said that, what seems immediately striking is just how unusual many of the offerings are, and how different they are from some of the more usual fare.
Cyril Barber
Of the three melodeon players, Cyril Barber’s two tracks demonstrate well the function of the music, with his Stepdance Tune, and also the means of transmission, with Sonny’s Tune, got from his brother. (2). It also shows that, to some musicians at least, tune names were not that important; less so than a description of function or origin, although this supposition cannot be applied across the board. Cyril Barber was a good step dancer in his day, and his contributions reflect well the functionality of this music
Cecil Pearl
Cecil Pearl is rather more extensively represented, with eight tracks, and here again we have direct reference to the source of tunes, with such as Dick Iris’ Hornpipe, Peachey’s Polkas and Alf Peachey’s March. (3) Of named tunes, La Russe, Marlborough’s March and Speed the Plough have not been commonly collected in the area, although they are broadly well known and the last of the three is the regimental march of the Royal Suffolks. Both men are solid, seasoned players with interesting tunes.
Dolly Curtis
Dolly Curtis really is the star of the show though, as regards the melodeon playing. Her bright, rhythmic playing sparkles across all five tracks of her playing, with tremendous lift, particularly with Brian Felgate’s piano backing. Seasoned collector Keith Summers, when advertising this LP’s forthcoming release in Musical Traditions magazine, stated that it comprised “three singers and three musicians, including my favourite melodeon player, Dolly Curtis. My original recordings of Dolly, intended for the LP Earl Soham Slog sadly were stolen, so this is good news indeed.” (4) Of her tunes presented here, the closing medley of Dennington Bell / On the Waggon still features prominently in Suffolk music events, or at least did until recently. (5)
Charlie Stringer
Of the singers, Charlie Stringer gets two songs, the unusual and rather comic Tommy Doddler and the locally better-known Kibosh the Cobbler (more frequently as Fagan the Cobbler), which he delivers in the declamatory style of someone well used to an audience. Fred Whiting has been much more extensively recorded as a fiddler, and a fine one at that, but he also had a large store of songs, collected along his travels, including the rare Poison Beer and rather defiant Who Owns the Game?, a reminder of the power of property rights invested in the landowning gentry and the dire penalties for poaching. This is coupled with Roy Last’s Botany Bay, on a similar theme, one of two occasions on the LP when a track is made up of a composite of similar or related material, although mercifully not at the expense of completeness.
Roy Last
Roy Last is showcased with seven songs, and once again his repertoire, as given here, is unusual, from the historical William Rufus to the locally topical Peter the Paynter. You can almost see the twinkle in his eye as he works his way through Little Cock Sparrow, learnt from an aunt when he was a little boy.
In all, this is a very satisfying record, one that I return to time and again. A good selection of the type of music and song prevalent in mid Suffolk pubs, when they were host to such goings-on, and also refreshingly different in content from some that is frequently found in the area. It is also well served by John Howson’s notes and a small booklet giving the words to the songs. The album is currently available as both CD and download from Veteran, and it’s one I would strongly urge the curious to seek out, if not already familiar with it.
Chris Holderness February 2026
Notes:
Who Owns the Game? Traditional Songs and Melodeon Tunes from Central Suffolk Veteran VT130CD (reissued in 2001) The CD version has a different cover from the LP.
Sonny Barber can be heard on the two CD set: The Pigeon on the Gate: Melodeon Players from East Anglia Veteran VTDC11CD, where there is also more from the three players showcased in this LP.
Alf Peachey’s melodeon playing was never recorded, apparently due to him keeping to an unfortunate promise made to his wife never to play again. He can be heard diddling tunes and singing on Out With Me Gun In the Morning Helions Bumpstead Gramophone Company NLCD14.
Musical Traditions No 3, Summer 1984, News section, p.26. John Howson’s article The Barber Family of Wingfield, Suffolk can be found in Musical Traditions No 2, Early 1984, pp. 19-23, and also online at www.mustrad.org.uk.
A recording which reflects this is The Old Hat Concert Party Old Hat OH1CD, which also has Cecil Pearl’s Hornpipes and Cyril Barber step dancing.
It is sixty years since the legendary English Country Music album was released as a private pressing, limited to 99 copies, as Record No 1, by Reg Hall and Bob Davenport. The LP was reissued more widely by Topic Records in 1976 (1) and then again, in greatly expanded form, on compact disc in 2000. (2) This situation alone demonstrates the enduring significance and influence of the record, particularly on the revival of interest in English instrumental music and dance tunes. An inauspicious start perhaps for a disc with which Reg Hall was taking chances by releasing a selection of recordings he and Mervyn Plunkett had made with Walter and Daisy Bulwer and Billy Cooper in 1962.
It is difficult to imagine now just how little information and how few recordings were available to enthusiasts sixty years ago, particularly to those of us too young to remember the situation first hand. The ‘renaissance’ of interest in traditional music in the 1970s, on both sides of the Atlantic, leading to the regular and sumptuous issues of traditional material by labels such as Topic and Leader in Britain, and Folkways and Rounder in the United States, not to mention the countless smaller concerns, were in the future. Most of these issues were exemplary in their packaging, with copious notes and photographs, providing a richness that went further than just what was contained in the grooves of the record. More recently, of course, despite the small audience for such music, a great deal has been issued on compact disc, with the same attention to detail and information, and continues to be so. In 1965 there was little available in Britain, a few limited-edition releases by the English Folk Dance and Song Society, and a few EPs of songs. Topic Records had begun to dip their toe into the water, with LPs by Jeannie Robertson, the Willett Family and Joe Heaney, but nobody had considered putting out a disc of traditional instrumental music: as Reg Hall stated in the CD booklet: “Topic was not ready for our sort of music” and wasn’t interested in releasing it.
To go back a few years, Reg Hall and Mervyn Plunkett, as enthusiasts for English traditional music, had started the West Hoathly Band of Music in Sussex, with several local traditional performers, including the formidable Scan Tester (3) in 1957. This band seems to have had a fluid line-up and some riotous nights in various pubs in that county and, as Reg related, “In October 1957 Mervyn arranged a coach trip to London. We entered Pop Maynard, Jean Hopkins, George Spicer, Bill Hawkes (4) and the full band in a competitive festival at Cecil Sharp House, headquarters of the English Folk Dance and Song Society. We shocked many of the people there and confused some of the adjudicators, who were used to genteel settings of folk songs… Very few of the audience had ever heard a country singer before, and even fewer had ever heard country pub music. Some of them, it seemed, were excited about it.” (5)
Mervyn Plunkett’s job as a salesman took him around the country and it was here that he came into contact with Walter Bulwer of Shipdham in Norfolk – the full story is related by Reg Hall in the CD booklet notes. Mervyn visited Walter and Daisy Bulwer several times and recorded Walter’s fiddle and mandolin-banjo playing in March 1959. (6) On 12 April of that year Reg accompanied Mervyn on a visit and “within minutes of the introduction, we were playing some of Walter’s tunes together. To our great amazement and delight, Walter soon left the lead to me and broke loose on some surprising and inventive second parts.” (7) The stage was set, particularly as Walter suggested that Mervyn should approach Billy Cooper, of nearby Hingham. Reg elaborates on this: “I got the impression, when we eventually brought them together, that they didn’t know each other, which now upon reflection seems very unlikely.” (8) In fact, Sam Steele had recorded the Bulwers and Billy Cooper playing together at some point between 1959 and 1962, on which occasion they certainly sound as if they were used to playing together (9).
The various participants met at the Bulwers’ cottage twice in 1960, in January and April, to record material. Due to several circumstances – Reg Hall again gives details in the CD booklet – these were not successful. Of these occasions, Reg comments: “Up until then our motives had been largely to do with the excitement of discovering the talents and inventiveness of the older musicians we had met and the fun of playing together. Very few people connected in any way with the folk-dance movement had not even the slightest notion of the existence of traditional instrumental music, and most commercial recordings of English country-dance were, to put it mildly, gutless” and that there was “our determination to make some sort of contribution to the world’s awareness and understanding of traditional music.” (10)
“The Saturday of the August Bank Holiday weekend in 1962 saw us all back together again; this time with Bill Leader recording for Topic Records.” (11) Mervyn Plunkett urged Russell Wortley to join in with his pipe-and-tabor, “to add tonal quality to the upper register.” On the second day Billy Cooper wasn’t available and “without him the band took on a quite different character.” For the second day, Harry Cox had also been brought along by Mervyn, but he “was, of course, a much rougher musician used to playing in his own time and rhythm and, not being able to make much of our way of playing, soon put his fiddle down. He enjoyed the rest of the day, however, listening to the music and joining in the banter.”
“We opened up the first session with our signature tune, Jenny Lind and The Girl I Left Behind Me.” (12) What followed was a series of polkas, waltzes, schottisches and hornpipes. Reg Hall gives a full account in the CD booklet, and I don’t propose to reproduce all of that here. Suffice to say that enough material had been gathered to consider an LP record, which Bill Leader was happy to edit, Reg having selected the performances with “the best starts and finishes, and the fewest mistakes”. (13) As has already been mentioned, Topic Records wasn’t interested in releasing the material and so Reg Hall and Bob Davenport prepared “a limited-edition long-playing record, which we issued in September 1965 as Record No.1 on our nameless label as the first of a series on a subscription basis. For tax reasons we could only make ninety-nine copies and surprisingly they were sold out in a fortnight.” (14)
For this limited release LP, thirteen tracks were selected from the sessions. A mixture of polka tunes, both obscure and un-named and well-known, such as Bluebell Polka, the jig Off She Goes (with an unusual second strain), two sets of medleys of waltz tunes, schottisches and well-known standard country dance tunes such as Jenny Lind Polka / Girl I Left Behind Me and The Four Hand Reel / Soldier’s Joy. In short, a good sample of the stock-in-trade of a southern English country musician, all with an infectious ready-to-dance jauntiness and loose ‘down-home’ feel. The LP concluded with an example of a tune Walter picked up when playing briefly for a morris side locally, Shepherd’s Hey. (15) Walter (fiddle and mandolin-banjo) and Daisy Bulwer (piano) and Billy Cooper (dulcimer), of the older generation, were joined by Reg Hall (melodeon and fiddle), Mervyn Plunkett (drums) and Russell Wortley (pipe-and-tabor) for what became an iconic sound and an inspiration for countless musicians later on.
This influence was not immediately apparent, however, and Reg Hall continues in the notes to point out that “Our exposure of Walter, Daisy and Billy to a larger world did not bring much interest to their doorsteps. Billy was dead by the time the record came out, but Walter and Daisy were pleased to receive visits from some younger musicians.” (16) However in 1974 Topic did use a couple of tracks from the sessions on their Boscastle Breakdown LP of southern English instrumental music and in 1976 the same label reissued Record No.1 as English Country Music. (17) Reg points out that the record had become a model for a new generation of musicians all over England, a couple of untitled polkas becoming particular favourites (18), much to his surprise, as being “too far removed from modern taste – even modern taste in traditional music.” (19)
In fact, it was just these polkas that attracted some musicians in the burgeoning English country music scene (of instrumentalists wishing to explore the range of traditional English country dance music), as Rod Stradling, leading light in that scene as a member of Oak and the The Old Swan Band, recalls: “I think that something I wrote in a review of Record No 1 English Country Music, when it was re-released on Topic in 2000, rather sums up the way I, and perhaps others, felt about our discovery of traditional English dance music back in the late-Sixties. In the Notes to the Topic release Reg Hall wrote that he was surprised that Walter Bulwer’s Untitled Polka should have become a favourite of the young English country music revival, since he felt that it was ‘so far removed from modern taste – even modern taste in traditional music’.
“My response was that: its appeal, apart from being a great tune, was precisely that it was ‘so far removed from modern taste’. We were, I think, unconsciously looking for ways to reclaim some sort of identity and cultural heritage in the face of the increasing Americanisation of our world – and the rising tide of badly-played Irish music amongst our English contemporaries. And it was precisely because it wasn’t one of the pop-song tunes of our parents’ generation, who had left us a legacy of world wars, the Holocaust, rationing, austerity, nuclear threat, sexual repression (the list seemed endless) that caused it to appeal so strongly to us. We picked on that tune particularly, for the same set of complicated reasons that we preferred (say) Fred Jordan to Martin Carthy or – more apposite – Bampton to Headington.
“But the fact that the music and the players were available to us provided a focus for the undefined yearnings for a music we could call our own. Almost uniquely, at that time, it was something we could fight for – whereas our adult experience of the world prior to that had been defined by our fighting against things.” (20)
So, influential and important indeed! It is certainly true that several of the tunes have endured well in the folk revival, particularly when a few more tracks were issued on the Topic LP Boscastle Breakdown in 1974 (as well as the reissue of Record No 1 in 1976). (21) A couple of untitled polkas in particular have become favourites, as alluded to by Rod Stradling above, although not always played in the style – or the keys – of Walter, et al. (22)
Katie Howson, co-founder of EATMT, had this to say: “Right from the opening bars of the first track I have always found this recording very exciting, and it still gives me goosebumps! Jenny Lind in one key led by Reg Hall on melodeon, Billy Cooper on dulcimer and Walter Bulwer on fiddle: simple and direct music that gets you in the guts and makes your feet move. I can remember how the scratchy fiddle playing, background coughing and slightly random accompaniment all added to the charm and seemed to make it somehow exotic, whilst at the same time being totally rooted in the locality.
“I would have heard this LP in 1977 or 78, before I moved to Suffolk, and this album (“the black album”) and English Country Music from East Anglia on the Topic label (“the white album”) were two things that made me want to move here and hear similar music in situ. Of course, by that time Walter Bulwer and Billy Cooper had died, but I was able to meet Billy Bennington, Oscar Woods and Harold Covill from “the white album” in person, and indeed become pals with Billy and Oscar.
“I also count myself exceptionally privileged to have spent much time with Reg Hall, one of the leading lights behind this recording. Over the course of five decades I have spent hours playing music with Reg – both English and Irish – and have had many long conversations with him about musical (and other) matters. He is known for his profound knowledge, writings and CD compilations for the Topic label and others, but his influence as a musician sometimes goes unrecognised and I would like to put on record here the huge inspiration he has been to me musically.
“The album is essential listening for anyone interested in English traditional music, and not only for the wealth of lovely tunes, but also for that special feeling of music-making bringing people together socially. “Folk” music always seems to me to be something from a book or manuscript, whereas in “traditional” music we can connect with previous generations in a much more personal way; their individual fingerprints are all over it, in a way which can be felt in recordings such as these. And wouldn’t Walter Bulwer be absolutely amazed if he dropped into a pub these days and found hordes of people playing the polkas he led for this recording? Rumour has it that they nearly didn’t make the edit, as sixty years ago they were felt to be a bit too modern in style!” (23)
On a personal note, of the bands promoting Norfolk’s traditional music I’ve been involved with, the 2020 CD Foundlings by the band Hushwing was an attempt to bring together and record a selection of obscure tunes from Norfolk, very much in the spirit of the original record, as mentioned in the booklet notes: “Our model has been the group of musicians gathered together by Mervyn Plunkett and Reg Hall for the recordings by Bill Leader made in 1962 at the home of Walter and Daisy Bulwer in Shipdham” (24) and perhaps the spirit of “these were not spotless performances in terms of recording studio multi-take perfection…these were lively, ready-for-dancing performances” (25) was very much present with our recording and the finished result. Certainly the original record was a great influence on proceedings in every respect.
So, it is fitting that the original Record No 1 of sixty years ago continues with its iconic status amongst musicians who are aficionados and proponents of English country dance music with a very traditional basis. Fitting too that the expanded CD version of English Country Music is still readily available, to continue to delight, inform and inspire. In fact, the CD version, vastly expanded in tracks as it is, gives a much wider sampling of what made these sessions so magical, providing more music by the older generation musicians in the sessions. In both versions, the album continues to play its part to ensure that the vernacular, traditional music of this area continues to thrive, albeit under different social circumstances from those when the Bulwers and Billy Cooper were active community musicians. To quote Lily Codling, the last surviving member of the Bulwers’ Time and Rhythm band of earlier in the Twentieth Century, about Walter’s probable reaction, “What would he feel now, he knew this all come about?” (26)
Chris Holderness November 2025
Notes:
English Country Music Topic 12T296
TSCD607
Scan Tester’s music was released extensively on the Topic 2 LP set: I Never Played to Many Posh Dances – 2-12T455/6 – in 1990. A slightly expanded CD version – TSCD581D – was released in 2009.
An EP featuring three of these singers was released on Collector Records in 1961: 4 Sussex Singers – JEB 7. It included songs by Jim Wilson, Pop Maynard, George Spicer and Jean Hopkins.
Reg Hall: I Never Played to Many Posh Dances: Scan Tester, Sussex Musician1887-1972 Musical Traditions supplement no. 2 (1990) p. 60. The LP set (Note 3, above) was released to accompany this publication.
Booklet notes by Reg Hall for the CD version of English Country Music p. 2
Ibid. Hall ECM p.3
Ibid. Hall ECM p.4
Heel and Toe Veteran VT150CD (2005). The tracks are: Yarmouth / Sailor’s / Yarmouth Hornpipes; Whistling Rufus and Unidentified Polka (Cromarty Polka March). Walter and Daisy Bulwer also play an Unidentified Jig (Warbler’s Serenade) and Billy Cooper plays Dulcie Bell.
Ibid. Hall ECM p. 5 & 6
Ibid. Hall ECM p. 7
Ibid. Hall ECM p.8
Rod Stradling, in his review of the Hushwing CD Foundlings: Musical Traditions 28.03.20
Ibid. Hall ECM p. 10
The track was not included on the CD version.
Ibid. Hall ECM p. 11
12T296, as above.
Now known popularly as Walter Bulwer’s Polka No 1 and Walter Bulwer’s Polka No 2. The first is track 3 on side 1. The second wasn’t included on the original LP but did appear on Topic’s LP Boscastle Breakdown: Southern English Country Music: 12T240, 1974, and is included in the CD edition. (The other Untitled Polka on the original LP – side 1, track 7 – is a version of the Helston Furry Dance.)
Ibid. Hall ECM p. 11
Rod Stradling, correspondence: 01.09.25. The review alluded to was published in Musical Traditions on 10.10.00.
12T196, as above. The first reissue in 1976 was housed in a gatefold sleeve. Later pressings were presented in a single sleeve.
In particular Walter’s No 2 Polka, which has three parts, the third of which is rarely played, unfortunately. He played the parts in F, C and B flat, again not as played usually today.
Katie Howson, correspondence: 19.11.25.
From the booklet notes by Alan Helsdon for the Hushwing Foundlings CD (Quanting QCD 20.03) 2020, p. 2.
Ibid. Helsdon p. 2.
Chris Holderness: Walter and Daisy Bulwer: Recollections of the Shipdham musicians by members of the community published in Musical Traditions: MT185, 25.08.06. This quote was used to conclude that article, but seems equally apposite here. A similar article with details of Billy Cooper’s life can be found at the same site: Billy Cooper: the Hingham dulcimer player remembered by his family: MT211, 16.07.07.
Appendix The tracks on Record No 1 (and the Topic LP reissue) are: Side 1: 01: The Bluebell Polka 02: Waltzes: The Foggy Dew / The Young Sailor Cut Down in His Prime 03: Untitled Polka 04: Jig: Off She Goes 05: Polka: Red Wing 06: Waltzes: Believe Me If Those Endearing Young Charms / Johnny’s So Long at the Fair 07: Untitled Polka (Helston Furry Dance) Side 2: 01: Polkas: Jenny Lind / The Girl I Left Behind Me 02: Peggy Wood / When There Isn’t a Girl About 03: Schottisches: Washing Day / Old Mrs Huddledee / The Cat’s Got the Measles 04: The Waltz Vienna 05: Hornpipes: The Four Hand Reel / Soldier’s Joy 06: Polka: Shepherd’s Hey